[rabbitmq-discuss] RabbitMQ with Socket Server

[Chuck Remes]

On Sep 14, 2009, at 8:09 PM, Alex Gentle wrote:

> >Alex, you haven't explained why your app can only send a specific
> >binary stream to a socket - for intents and purposes AMQP is no more
> >than a *stream* of binary data.
>
> I am not sure. It's not a specific binary stream, it can be any  
> binary data. But, this binary data can't be interpreted by RabbitMQ  
> unless I put another middle layer to translate this into call to  
> RabbitMQ.
>
> >I don't know how the network event notification works in iPhone OS  
> 3.x
> >(i.e. I don't know whether you get it to pre-empt the phone's  
> kernel).
>
> Actually it's not related to iPhone. I was mentioning about polling  
> mechanism in RabbitMQ. Meaning that, RabbitMQ doesn't inform the  
> user when he gets the message. User has to check every few seconds  
> to see if there is anything in his queue. So, iPhone app (OR any  
> application for that matter) needs to constantly check RabbitMQ to  
> see if there is any message. That's going to cost lot of bandwidth  
> when I port the app to mobile devices.
>
> Thank you for all the answers.

You don't need AMQP on your client side at all based upon your  
descriptions. You already have a methodology for contacting a server  
(the socket connection described). The only role for AMQP would be on  
the server side.

I think you might be trying to squeeze AMQP (and rabbit) into a place  
where it doesn't fit.

Why don't you try describing your entire messaging architecture for  
us. Perhaps we can suggest improvements.

cr